This site's latest PAC 10 rankings

[bronco]

Overall they look pretty good and well reasoned. There are only a few things that I would question.

# 1. Why these latest PAC 10 rankings have Charlie Alexander of Oregon ranked ahead of Nick Smith of Boise State when Nick Smith just defeated Charlie Alexander in the dual meet between Boise State and Oregon last Friday.

# 2. Why is Ryan Dunn of Oregon ranked two spots ahead of Arizona State's Todd Schavrien when Schavrien beat Dunn 19-14 last Sunday in the dual meet between ASU and Oregon?

# 3. Why is Teddy Bristol ranked 6th at 165 lbs yet Zack Frazier of Oregon is ranked 9th when Frazier defeated Bristol 9-4 this season?

[Earl]

Thanks Bronco....

1) Lack of Proofreading...That was on my "worksheet" and didn't make it's way onto the real ones.

2) Schavrien was ranked one spot lower in last weeks rankings and moved ahead of Kimbrell with his win over Dunn. What makes things difficult is Novachkov. I know you stay on top of things, so I'm sure you know he has a lost to Dunn, but has 2 wins over Schavrien. I didn't think it was right to jump Schavrien three spots (included 1 guy he lost to twice) just for one victory.

3. That is just an error that will be corrected.

[bronco]

Thanks for the very honest reply Earl. As I said - overall they appear to be VERY well done and well reasoned. Nice job.

As to the Schavrien vs. Dunn thing - I know what you are saying - there are several similar examples in the PAC 10. It makes ranking some weight classes very difficult.